laph02
Sep 19 2011, 05:14 PM
Hello,
I had a situation occur this past weekend in a C class tourney that I was hoping someone could address. I threw a drive into heavy trees, on the right side of the fairway, and we never saw it come out. As I went searching I found "my" orange disc sitting in the top of a palm tree. I told my group members that I thought that was my disc. It was about 20-25 feet up, and partially covered by palm fronds. We were not playing the 2 meter rule, so I marked below the tree, and proceeded on. After the round I asked a friend to retrieve the disc. When he did, it was not my disc. I informed the TD and he used the rule on playing an incorrect lie and gave me a 2 stroke penalty. I have a couple of questions. Was that the proper rule to invoke, even after the round was complete? Should I have been DQ'd because I signed a wrong scorecard? It turned out to be significant because I finished
2nd, 1 shot out of first, which would be a moot point if I were to be dq'd. Any thoughts are appreciated.
Phil Rowe
I had a situation occur this past weekend in a C class tourney that I was hoping someone could address. I threw a drive into heavy trees, on the right side of the fairway, and we never saw it come out. As I went searching I found "my" orange disc sitting in the top of a palm tree. I told my group members that I thought that was my disc. It was about 20-25 feet up, and partially covered by palm fronds. We were not playing the 2 meter rule, so I marked below the tree, and proceeded on. After the round I asked a friend to retrieve the disc. When he did, it was not my disc. I informed the TD and he used the rule on playing an incorrect lie and gave me a 2 stroke penalty. I have a couple of questions. Was that the proper rule to invoke, even after the round was complete? Should I have been DQ'd because I signed a wrong scorecard? It turned out to be significant because I finished
2nd, 1 shot out of first, which would be a moot point if I were to be dq'd. Any thoughts are appreciated.
Phil Rowe